Comparison of the effects of a monounsaturated fat diet and a high carbohydrate diet on cardiovascular risk factors in first degree relatives to type-2 diabetic subjects.
Study Goal
The researchers aimed to compare the effects of a high-carbohydrate diet versus a monounsaturated fatty acid (MUFA)-rich diet on cardiovascular risk factors in individuals at high risk of developing Type-2 diabetes.
Results Summary
The study found that both diets had similar effects on total cholesterol, LDL-cholesterol, triglycerides, and apoB levels. The MUFA diet showed slightly higher HDL-cholesterol and apoA-1 levels, but insulin sensitivity, blood pressure, and vWF levels were similar between the diets.
Population
Sixteen healthy first-degree relatives of Type-2 diabetes patients (6 men, 10 women, mean age 35±2 years) with normal glucose tolerance.
Effective Dosage
55% of energy from carbohydrates, 30% from fat, 15% from protein (CHO diet).
Duration
Two 4-week treatment periods separated by a 4-week wash-out.
Interactions
None mentioned
| Intervention | Direction | Endpoint | Population | Dosage | Impact | Claim # |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
diet rich in olive oil (MUFA diet) | increase | high-density lipoprotein (HDL)-cholesterol | first-degree relatives of Type-2 DM patients | 1.4+/-0.4 vs 1.3+/-0.4 mmol/l | slightly higher levels | #1 |
diet rich in olive oil (MUFA diet) | increase | apoA-1 | first-degree relatives of Type-2 DM patients | 1.2+/-0.3 vs 1.1+/-0.3 mmol/l | slightly higher levels | #2 |
diet rich in olive oil (MUFA diet) | decrease | total cholesterol | first-degree relatives of Type-2 DM patients | - | similar lowering effects | #3 |
diet rich in olive oil (MUFA diet) | decrease | low density lipoprotein (LDL)-cholesterol | first-degree relatives of Type-2 DM patients | - | similar lowering effects | #4 |
diet rich in olive oil (MUFA diet) | decrease | triglyceride | first-degree relatives of Type-2 DM patients | - | similar lowering effects | #5 |
diet rich in olive oil (MUFA diet) | decrease | apoB levels | first-degree relatives of Type-2 DM patients | - | similar lowering effects | #6 |
diet rich in olive oil (MUFA diet) | no change | insulin sensitivity | first-degree relatives of Type-2 DM patients | - | similar | #7 |
diet rich in olive oil (MUFA diet) | no change | first response insulin areas | first-degree relatives of Type-2 DM patients | - | similar | #8 |
diet rich in olive oil (MUFA diet) | no change | 24-h blood pressures | first-degree relatives of Type-2 DM patients | - | similar | #9 |
diet rich in olive oil (MUFA diet) | no change | von Willebrand Factor (vWF) levels | first-degree relatives of Type-2 DM patients | - | similar | #10 |
carbohydrate-rich (CHO) diet | decrease | total cholesterol | first-degree relatives of Type-2 DM patients | - | similar lowering effects | #11 |
carbohydrate-rich (CHO) diet | decrease | low density lipoprotein (LDL)-cholesterol | first-degree relatives of Type-2 DM patients | - | similar lowering effects | #12 |
carbohydrate-rich (CHO) diet | decrease | triglyceride | first-degree relatives of Type-2 DM patients | - | similar lowering effects | #13 |
carbohydrate-rich (CHO) diet | decrease | apoB levels | first-degree relatives of Type-2 DM patients | - | similar lowering effects | #14 |
carbohydrate-rich (CHO) diet | no change | insulin sensitivity | first-degree relatives of Type-2 DM patients | - | similar | #15 |
carbohydrate-rich (CHO) diet | no change | first response insulin areas | first-degree relatives of Type-2 DM patients | - | similar | #16 |
carbohydrate-rich (CHO) diet | no change | 24-h blood pressures | first-degree relatives of Type-2 DM patients | - | similar | #17 |
carbohydrate-rich (CHO) diet | no change | von Willebrand Factor (vWF) levels | first-degree relatives of Type-2 DM patients | - | similar | #18 |
OBJECTIVE: Recent studies have demonstrated beneficial metabolic effects of dietary monounsaturated fatty acids (MUFA) in Type-2 diabetes mellitus (Type-2 DM). The question arises if dietary MUFA also has desirable effects on risk markers in subjects with high risk of developing Type-2 DM. SETTING: University department of endocrinology. SUBJECTS: Sixteen healthy, first-degree relatives (six men, 10 women, age (mean+/-s.d.): 35+/-2 years) with normal oral glucose tolerance tests. INTERVENTIONS: Randomised study with two 4-week treatment periods with either a carbohydrate-rich (CHO) diet (55 E% carbohydrate, 30 E% fat, 15 E% protein) or a diet rich in olive oil [MUFA 40 E% fat (25 E% as MUFA), 45 E% carbohydrate, 15 E% protein]. The periods were divided by a 4-week wash-out period. RESULTS: Similar lowering effects on total cholesterol, low density lipoprotein (LDL)-cholesterol, triglyceride and apoB levels were seen after the two diets. Slightly higher levels of high-density lipoprotein (HDL)-cholesterol (1.4+/-0.4 vs 1.3+/-0.4 mmol/l, P<0. 0001) and apoA-1 (1.2+/-0.3 vs 1.1+/-0.3 mmol/l, P<0.05) were found in the MUFA-diet. Furthermore, the insulin sensitivity, as assessed by Bergman's minimal model, and the first response insulin areas were similar, as were the 24-h blood pressures and the von Willebrand Factor (vWF) levels. CONCLUSIONS: Isocaloric diets rich in MUFA or rich in carbohydrate, respectively, seem to have similar effects on cardiovascular risk factors in persons at high risk of developing Type-2 DM. A potential risk, however, on body weight of high-fat diets should be kept in mind. SPONSORSHIP: This study was supported by grants from the Danish Diabetes Association, Institute of Clinical Experimental Research, Aarhus University, The Danish Heart Foundation, The Danish Medical Research Council, Velux Foundation, Poul and Erna Sehested Hansens Foundation, Mogens Svarre Mogensens Foundation.