Panacea Index Logo

Command Palette

Search for a command to run...

Does postoperative 'M' technique massage with or without mandarin oil reduce infants' distress after major craniofacial surgery?

Journal of advanced nursing
August 1, 2012
Marjan de Jong et al. (6 authors)
Journal ArticleRandomized Controlled TrialHuman StudyClinical
Study Details

Study Goal

The researchers aimed to determine whether 'M' technique massage with or without mandarin oil could reduce pain, distress, heart rate, and mean arterial pressure in infants after major craniofacial surgery compared to standard postoperative care.

Results Summary

The study found no statistically significant benefit of 'M' technique massage with or without mandarin oil on pain, distress, or physiological measures in postoperative infants. Heart rate and mean arterial pressure changed significantly over time, but these changes were unrelated to the massage intervention.

Population

Infants aged 3-36 months who underwent major craniofacial surgery.

Effective Dosage

Not specified

Duration

Not specified

Interactions

None mentioned

Extracted Claims (10)
InterventionDirectionEndpointPopulationDosageImpactClaim #
'M' technique massage with carrier oil
increase
COMFORT behaviour scores
children aged 3-36 months after craniofacial surgery
not statistically significant
mean postintervention scores were higher than baseline scores, but differences were not statistically significant
#1
'M' technique massage with mandarin oil
increase
COMFORT behaviour scores
children aged 3-36 months after craniofacial surgery
not statistically significant
mean postintervention scores were higher than baseline scores, but differences were not statistically significant
#2
standard postoperative care
increase
COMFORT behaviour scores
children aged 3-36 months after craniofacial surgery
not statistically significant
mean postintervention scores were higher than baseline scores, but differences were not statistically significant
#3
'M' technique massage with carrier oil
no change
Heart rate
children aged 3-36 months after craniofacial surgery
statistically significant change
showed a statistically significant change across the three assessment periods
#4
'M' technique massage with carrier oil
no change
mean arterial pressure
children aged 3-36 months after craniofacial surgery
statistically significant change
showed a statistically significant change across the three assessment periods
#5
'M' technique massage with mandarin oil
no change
Heart rate
children aged 3-36 months after craniofacial surgery
statistically significant change
showed a statistically significant change across the three assessment periods
#6
'M' technique massage with mandarin oil
no change
mean arterial pressure
children aged 3-36 months after craniofacial surgery
statistically significant change
showed a statistically significant change across the three assessment periods
#7
standard postoperative care
no change
Heart rate
children aged 3-36 months after craniofacial surgery
statistically significant change
showed a statistically significant change across the three assessment periods
#8
standard postoperative care
no change
mean arterial pressure
children aged 3-36 months after craniofacial surgery
statistically significant change
showed a statistically significant change across the three assessment periods
#9
'M' technique massage with or without mandarin oil
no change
pain and distress
young postoperative patients
-
Results do not support a benefit
#10
Abstract

AIM: This article is a report of a randomized controlled trial of the effects of 'M' technique massage with or without mandarin oil compared to standard postoperative care on infants' levels of pain and distress, heart rate and mean arterial pressure after major craniofacial surgery. BACKGROUND: There is a growing interest in non-pharmacological interventions such as aromatherapy massage in hospitalized children to relieve pain and distress but well performed studies are lacking. METHODS: This randomized controlled trial allocated 60 children aged 3-36 months after craniofacial surgery from January 2008 to August 2009 to one of three conditions; 'M' technique massage with carrier oil, 'M' technique massage with mandarin oil or standard postoperative care. Primary outcome measures were changes in COMFORT behaviour scores, Numeric Rating Scale pain and Numeric Rating Scale distress scores assessed from videotape by an observer blinded for the condition. RESULTS: In all three groups, the mean postintervention COMFORT behaviour scores were higher than the baseline scores, but differences were not statistically significant. Heart rate and mean arterial pressure showed a statistically significant change across the three assessment periods in all three groups. These changes were not related with the intervention. CONCLUSIONS: Results do not support a benefit of 'M' technique massage with or without mandarin oil in these young postoperative patients. Several reasons may account for this: massage given too soon after general anaesthesia, young patients' fear of strangers touching them, patients not used to massage.

Medical Subject Headings (MeSH)
Analysis of VarianceAromatherapyChild, HospitalizedChild, PreschoolCitrusClinical Nursing ResearchCraniosynostosesFemaleHumansInfantIntensive Care Units, PediatricMaleMassageOils, VolatileOutcome Assessment, Health CarePain MeasurementPain, PostoperativePlant OilsPostoperative CareRegression AnalysisStress, PsychologicalSurgical Procedures, Operative
Study Links
Quality Scores
Safety80
Efficacy30/10
Quality75/10
Citation Metrics
Total Citations18
Citations/Year1.4
Relative Citation Ratio1.01
NIH Percentile50.7%
Research Impact Scores
APT Score0.50
Weight Score1.36
Normalized Score0.59
Related Supplements
Does postoperative 'M' technique massage with or without man... | Panacea Index