Panacea Index Logo

Command Palette

Search for a command to run...

Evidence-based options for treatment-resistant adult bipolar disorder patients.

Bipolar disorders
September 1, 2012
Shi Hui Poon et al. (5 authors)
Journal ArticleResearch Support, Non-U.S. Gov'tReviewHuman Study
Study Details

Study Goal

The researchers aimed to evaluate the effectiveness of light therapy as a treatment for resistant bipolar depression.

Results Summary

The study found light therapy to be a promising but limited treatment for treatment-resistant bipolar depression, alongside other interventions like anticonvulsants, antipsychotics, and behavioral therapies. Most trials, including those for light therapy, were methodologically limited with small sample sizes and brief follow-up.

Population

Patients with treatment-resistant bipolar disorder, particularly those experiencing depressive-dysthymic-dysphoric-mixed phases.

Effective Dosage

Not specified

Duration

Not specified

Interactions

None mentioned

Extracted Claims (21)
InterventionDirectionEndpointPopulationDosageImpactClaim #
clozapine
no change
treatment-resistant bipolar mania
patients with bipolar disorder
null
few promising leads other than the use of
#1
anticonvulsants
no change
treatment-resistant bipolar depression
patients with bipolar disorder
null
promising but limited in effectiveness
#2
modern antipsychotics
no change
treatment-resistant bipolar depression
patients with bipolar disorder
null
promising but limited in effectiveness
#3
glutamate [N-methyl-D-aspartate (NMDA)] antagonists
no change
treatment-resistant bipolar depression
patients with bipolar disorder
null
promising but limited in effectiveness
#4
dopamine agonists
no change
treatment-resistant bipolar depression
patients with bipolar disorder
null
promising but limited in effectiveness
#5
calcium-channel blockers
no change
treatment-resistant bipolar depression
patients with bipolar disorder
null
promising but limited in effectiveness
#6
thyroid hormones
no change
treatment-resistant bipolar depression
patients with bipolar disorder
null
promising but limited in effectiveness
#7
behavioral therapy
no change
treatment-resistant bipolar depression
patients with bipolar disorder
null
promising but limited in effectiveness
#8
sleep deprivation
no change
treatment-resistant bipolar depression
patients with bipolar disorder
null
promising but limited in effectiveness
#9
light therapy
no change
treatment-resistant bipolar depression
patients with bipolar disorder
null
promising but limited in effectiveness
#10
electroconvulsive therapy (ECT)
no change
treatment-resistant bipolar depression
patients with bipolar disorder
null
promising but limited in effectiveness
#11
transcranial magnetic stimulation
no change
treatment-resistant bipolar depression
patients with bipolar disorder
null
promising but limited in effectiveness
#12
deep brain stimulation
no change
treatment-resistant bipolar depression
patients with bipolar disorder
null
promising but limited in effectiveness
#13
an anticholinesterase
increase
long-term treatment of resistant BD
resistant BD patients
null
have some support
#14
a glutamine antagonist
increase
long-term treatment of resistant BD
resistant BD patients
null
have some support
#15
a calcium-channel blocker
increase
long-term treatment of resistant BD
resistant BD patients
null
have some support
#16
triiodothyronine
increase
long-term treatment of resistant BD
resistant BD patients
null
have some support
#17
olanzapine
increase
long-term treatment of resistant BD
resistant BD patients
null
have some support
#18
topiramate
increase
long-term treatment of resistant BD
resistant BD patients
null
have some support
#19
electroconvulsive therapy (ECT)
increase
long-term treatment of resistant BD
resistant BD patients
null
have some support
#20
cognitive-behavior therapy
increase
long-term treatment of resistant BD
resistant BD patients
null
have some support
#21
Abstract

OBJECTIVES: Many patients diagnosed with bipolar disorder (BD) respond incompletely or unsatisfactorily to available treatments. Given the potentially devastating nature of this prevalent disorder, there is a pressing need to improve clinical care of such patients. METHODS: We performed a literature review of the research findings related to treatment-resistant BD reported through February 2012. RESULTS: Therapeutic trials for treatment-resistant bipolar mania are uncommon, and provide few promising leads other than the use of clozapine. Far more pressing challenges are the depressive-dysthymic-dysphoric-mixed phases of BD and long-term prophylaxis. Therapeutic trials for treatment-resistant bipolar depression have assessed anticonvulsants, modern antipsychotics, glutamate [N-methyl-D-aspartate (NMDA)] antagonists, dopamine agonists, calcium-channel blockers, and thyroid hormones, as well as behavioral therapy, sleep deprivation, light therapy, electroconvulsive therapy (ECT), transcranial magnetic stimulation, and deep brain stimulation-all of which are promising but limited in effectiveness. Several innovative pharmacological treatments (an anticholinesterase, a glutamine antagonist, a calcium-channel blocker, triiodothyronine, olanzapine and topiramate), ECT, and cognitive-behavior therapy have some support for long-term treatment of resistant BD patients, but most of trials of these treatments have been methodologically limited. CONCLUSIONS: Most studies identified were small, involved supplementation of typically complex ongoing treatments, varied in controls, randomization, and blinding, usually involved brief follow-up, and lacked replication. Clearer criteria for defining and predicting treatment resistance in BD are needed, as well as improved trial design with better controls, assessment of specific clinical subgroups, and longer follow-up.

Medical Subject Headings (MeSH)
AdultAnticonvulsantsAntipsychotic AgentsBehavior TherapyBipolar DisorderCalcium Channel BlockersCombined Modality TherapyDeep Brain StimulationDepressive Disorder, Treatment-ResistantDopamine AgonistsElectroconvulsive TherapyExcitatory Amino Acid AntagonistsHumansPhototherapyThyroid HormonesTranscranial Magnetic Stimulation
Study Links
Quality Scores
SafetyNot Assessed
Efficacy65/10
Quality50/10
Citation Metrics
Total Citations44
Citations/Year3.4
Relative Citation Ratio1.71
NIH Percentile69.5%
Research Impact Scores
APT Score0.75
Weight Score1.16
Normalized Score0.56
Related Supplements