Panacea Index Logo

Command Palette

Search for a command to run...

Randomized clinical trial of adapted mindfulness-based stress reduction versus group cognitive behavioral therapy for heterogeneous anxiety disorders.

Behaviour research and therapy
May 1, 2013
Joanna J Arch et al. (6 authors)
Journal ArticleRandomized Controlled TrialHuman StudyClinical
Study Details

Study Goal

The researchers aimed to compare the effectiveness of mindfulness-based stress reduction (MBSR) and cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) in treating anxiety disorders among veterans.

Results Summary

Both MBSR and CBT showed large and equivalent improvements in principal disorder severity. CBT was more effective at reducing anxious arousal, while MBSR was more effective at reducing worry and comorbid emotional disorders.

Population

105 veterans (83% male, mean age 46 years, 30% minority) with DSM-IV anxiety disorders.

Effective Dosage

Not specified

Duration

Not specified (follow-up at 3 months)

Interactions

None mentioned

Extracted Claims (12)
InterventionDirectionEndpointPopulationDosageImpactClaim #
adapted mindfulness-based stress reduction (MBSR)
decrease
principal disorder severity
veterans with one or more DSM-IV anxiety disorders
d=-4.08
showed large and equivalent improvements
#1
cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT)
decrease
principal disorder severity
veterans with one or more DSM-IV anxiety disorders
d=-3.52
showed large and equivalent improvements
#2
cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT)
decrease
anxious arousal outcomes
veterans with one or more DSM-IV anxiety disorders
d=.49
outperformed adapted MBSR
#3
adapted mindfulness-based stress reduction (MBSR)
decrease
worry
veterans with one or more DSM-IV anxiety disorders
d=.64
reduced worry at a greater rate
#4
adapted mindfulness-based stress reduction (MBSR)
decrease
comorbid emotional disorders
veterans with one or more DSM-IV anxiety disorders
d=.49
resulted in greater reduction
#5
adapted mindfulness-based stress reduction (MBSR)
neutral
mood disorders and worry
veterans with one or more DSM-IV anxiety disorders
-
evidenced greater
#6
cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT)
decrease
principal diagnosis severity
complex sample
-
were both effective at reducing
#7
adapted mindfulness-based stress reduction (MBSR)
decrease
principal diagnosis severity
complex sample
-
were both effective at reducing
#8
cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT)
decrease
self-reported anxiety symptoms
complex sample
-
somewhat effective at reducing
#9
adapted mindfulness-based stress reduction (MBSR)
decrease
self-reported anxiety symptoms
complex sample
-
somewhat effective at reducing
#10
cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT)
decrease
anxious arousal
complex sample
-
more effective at reducing
#11
adapted mindfulness-based stress reduction (MBSR)
decrease
worry and comorbid disorders
complex sample
-
may be more effective at reducing
#12
Abstract

OBJECTIVE: To compare a mindfulness-based intervention with cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) for the group treatment of anxiety disorders. METHOD: One hundred five veterans (83% male, mean age=46 years, 30% minority) with one or more DSM-IV anxiety disorders began group treatment following randomization to adapted mindfulness-based stress reduction (MBSR) or CBT. RESULTS: Both groups showed large and equivalent improvements on principal disorder severity thru 3-month follow up (ps<.001, d=-4.08 for adapted MBSR; d=-3.52 for CBT). CBT outperformed adapted MBSR on anxious arousal outcomes at follow up (p<.01, d=.49) whereas adapted MBSR reduced worry at a greater rate than CBT (p<.05, d=.64) and resulted in greater reduction of comorbid emotional disorders (p<.05, d=.49). The adapted MBSR group evidenced greater mood disorders and worry at Pre, however. Groups showed equivalent treatment credibility, therapist adherence and competency, and reliable improvement. CONCLUSIONS: CBT and adapted MBSR were both effective at reducing principal diagnosis severity and somewhat effective at reducing self-reported anxiety symptoms within a complex sample. CBT was more effective at reducing anxious arousal, whereas adapted MBSR may be more effective at reducing worry and comorbid disorders.

Medical Subject Headings (MeSH)
AdultAgedAnxiety DisordersAwarenessCognitive Behavioral TherapyFemaleHumansLongitudinal StudiesMaleMiddle AgedMind-Body TherapiesStress, PsychologicalSurveys and QuestionnairesTreatment OutcomeVeteransYoung Adult
Study Links
Quality Scores
SafetyNot Assessed
Efficacy85/10
Quality90/10
Citation Metrics
Total Citations69
Citations/Year5.8
Relative Citation Ratio3.29
NIH Percentile86.8%
Research Impact Scores
APT Score0.75
Weight Score1.79
Normalized Score0.72
Related Supplements