Panacea Index Logo

Command Palette

Search for a command to run...

Complementary therapies in addition to medication for patients with nonchronic, nonradicular low back pain: a systematic review.

The American journal of emergency medicine
January 1, 2017
Samantha Rothberg et al. (2 authors)
Journal ArticleReviewSystematic ReviewHuman Study
Study Details

Study Goal

The researchers aimed to determine whether massage, when combined with standard medical therapy, improves pain and functional outcomes more than standard medical therapy alone in patients with nonchronic low back pain.

Results Summary

The study did not identify any eligible trials evaluating massage therapy, so no conclusions could be drawn about its efficacy for nonchronic low back pain.

Population

Patients with nonradicular low back pain of less than 12 weeks' duration.

Effective Dosage

Not available

Duration

Not available

Interactions

None mentioned

Extracted Claims (6)
InterventionDirectionEndpointPopulationDosageImpactClaim #
chiropractic manipulation + medical therapy
no change
pain scores or measures of functionality
patients with nonradicular LBP of <12 weeks' duration
no significant change
failed to show benefit
#1
exercise therapy + medical therapy
no change
pain scores or measures of functionality
patients with nonradicular LBP of <12 weeks' duration
no significant change
failed to show benefit
#2
spinal manipulation
no change
pain and functional outcomes
patients with nonchronic, nonradicular LBP
-
does not support the use
#3
exercise therapy
no change
pain and functional outcomes
patients with nonchronic, nonradicular LBP
-
does not support the use
#4
yoga
neutral
pain and functional outcomes
patients with nonchronic, nonradicular LBP
-
insufficient evidence to determine if beneficial
#5
massage therapy
neutral
pain and functional outcomes
patients with nonchronic, nonradicular LBP
-
insufficient evidence to determine if beneficial
#6
Abstract

BACKGROUND: A total of 2.7 million patients present to US emergency departments annually for management of low back pain (LBP). Despite optimal medical therapy, more than 50% remain functionally impaired 3 months later. We performed a systematic review to address the following question: Among patients with nonchronic LBP, does spinal manipulation, massage, exercise, or yoga, when combined with standard medical therapy, improve pain and functional outcomes more than standard medical therapy alone? METHODS: We used published searches to identify relevant studies, supplemented with our own updated search. Studies were culled from the Cochrane Register of Controlled Trials, Medline, EMBASE, CINAHL, and the Index to Chiropractic Literature. Our goal was to identify randomized studies that included patients with nonradicular LBP of <12 weeks' duration that compared the complementary therapy to usual care, sham therapy, or interventions known not to be efficacious, while providing all patients with standard analgesics. The outcomes of interest were improvement in pain scores or measures of functionality. RESULTS: We identified 2 randomized controlled trials in which chiropractic manipulation + medical therapy failed to show benefit vs medical therapy alone. We identified 4 randomized controlled trials in which exercise therapy + medical therapy failed to show benefit vs medical therapy alone. We did not identify any eligible studies of yoga or massage therapy. CONCLUSIONS: In conclusion, for patients with nonchronic, nonradicular LBP, available evidence does not support the use of spinal manipulation or exercise therapy in addition to standard medical therapy. There is insufficient evidence to determine if yoga or massage is beneficial.

Medical Subject Headings (MeSH)
AnalgesicsCombined Modality TherapyComplementary TherapiesExercise TherapyHumansLow Back PainManipulation, SpinalMassagePain ManagementYoga
Study Links
Quality Scores
SafetyNot Assessed
Quality75/10
Citation Metrics
Total Citations9
Citations/Year1.1
Relative Citation Ratio0.51
NIH Percentile27.5%
Research Impact Scores
APT Score0.50
Weight Score1.80
Normalized Score0.55
Related Supplements