Dry needling versus friction massage to treat tension type headache: A randomized clinical trial.
Study Goal
The researchers aimed to compare the effectiveness of dry needling and friction massage in reducing headache frequency and intensity in patients with tension-type headache (TTH).
Results Summary
Both dry needling and friction massage significantly reduced headache frequency and intensity and increased pain threshold at trigger points, with no significant differences between the two treatments except for pain threshold, where dry needling was superior. Neither treatment affected cervical range of motion except for extension, which improved with dry needling.
Population
44 patients with tension-type headache (TTH).
Effective Dosage
3 sessions during 1 week.
Duration
1 week.
Interactions
None mentioned.
| Intervention | Direction | Endpoint | Population | Dosage | Impact | Claim # |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
dry needling | decrease | headache frequency | patients with TTH | - | significantly reduced | #1 |
dry needling | decrease | headache intensity | patients with TTH | - | significantly reduced | #2 |
dry needling | increase | pain threshold at the trigger points | patients with TTH | - | increased | #3 |
dry needling | increase | cervical range of motion for extension | patients with TTH | - | increased | #4 |
dry needling | no change | cervical range of motion | patients with TTH | - | had no effect | #5 |
friction massage | decrease | headache frequency | patients with TTH | - | significantly reduced | #6 |
friction massage | decrease | headache intensity | patients with TTH | - | significantly reduced | #7 |
friction massage | increase | pain threshold at the trigger points | patients with TTH | - | increased | #8 |
friction massage | no change | cervical range of motion | patients with TTH | - | had no effect | #9 |
dry needling | increase | pain threshold | patients with TTH | - | increased pain threshold significantly more than friction massage | #10 |
dry needling | no change | other outcome variables | patients with TTH | - | no significant differences | #11 |
friction massage | no change | other outcome variables | patients with TTH | - | no significant differences | #12 |
Tension type headache (TTH), the most common type of headache, is known to be associated with myofascial pain syndrome and the existence of myofascial trigger points. There are several treatment options for myofascial trigger points. In this study we compared the effectiveness of dry needling and friction massage to treat patients with TTH. A convenience sample of 44 patients with TTH participated in this randomized clinical trial. The frequency and intensity of headache, pressure pain threshold at the trigger point site, and cervical range of motion were recorded. Then the participants were randomly assigned to one of two treatment groups for dry needling or friction massage, delivered in 3 sessions during 1 week. The participants were evaluated 48 h after the last treatment session. Analysis of covariance, paired t-test and Wilcoxon's test were used for statistical analysis. The results showed that both treatment methods significantly reduced headache frequency and intensity, and increased pain threshold at the trigger points. However, neither treatment had any effect on cervical range of motion except for extension, which increased in the dry needling group. Between-group comparisons showed that dry needling increased pain threshold significantly more than friction massage. There were no significant differences between groups in any other outcome variables. Dry needling and friction massage were equally effective in improving symptoms in patients with TTH. The decreases in frequency and intensity of headache were similar after both dry needing and friction massage.