Mindfulness to enhance quality of life and support advance care planning: a pilot randomized controlled trial for adults with advanced cancer and their family caregivers.
Study Goal
The researchers aimed to evaluate the preliminary efficacy of a mindfulness-based intervention (MEANING) in improving quality of life and advance care planning engagement for patient-caregiver dyads coping with advanced cancer.
Results Summary
The MEANING intervention significantly improved existential well-being and self-efficacy for advance care planning in patients, with moderate increases in psychological well-being and caregiver quality of life. Other outcomes, such as caregiver burden and readiness for advance care planning, showed moderate improvement but were not statistically significant.
Population
Patient-caregiver dyads coping with advanced cancer recruited from five oncology clinics in the midwestern U.S.
Effective Dosage
Six weekly group sessions of mindfulness intervention.
Duration
6 weeks
Interactions
None mentioned
| Intervention | Direction | Endpoint | Population | Dosage | Impact | Claim # |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Mindfulness to Enhance Quality of Life and Support Advance Care Planning (MEANING) intervention | increase | existential well-being | Patients in the MEANING condition | significant increases | experienced significant increases | #1 |
Mindfulness to Enhance Quality of Life and Support Advance Care Planning (MEANING) intervention | increase | self-efficacy for advance care planning | Patients in the MEANING condition | significant increases | experienced significant increases | #2 |
Mindfulness to Enhance Quality of Life and Support Advance Care Planning (MEANING) intervention | increase | psychological well-being | MEANING patients | moderate increases | showed moderate increases | #3 |
Mindfulness to Enhance Quality of Life and Support Advance Care Planning (MEANING) intervention | increase | quality of life | MEANING caregivers | moderate increases | showed moderate increases | #4 |
Mindfulness to Enhance Quality of Life and Support Advance Care Planning (MEANING) intervention | decrease | caregiver burden | MEANING condition | moderate improvement | showed moderate improvement | #5 |
Mindfulness to Enhance Quality of Life and Support Advance Care Planning (MEANING) intervention | increase | quality-of-life and advance care planning outcomes | patients and caregivers coping with advanced cancer | - | showed promise in improving | #6 |
Mindfulness to Enhance Quality of Life and Support Advance Care Planning (MEANING) intervention | no change | other facets of patient well-being | patients | not statistically significant | were not statistically significant | #7 |
Mindfulness to Enhance Quality of Life and Support Advance Care Planning (MEANING) intervention | no change | caregiver quality of life | caregivers | not statistically significant | were not statistically significant | #8 |
Mindfulness to Enhance Quality of Life and Support Advance Care Planning (MEANING) intervention | no change | patient readiness for advance care planning | patients | not statistically significant | were not statistically significant | #9 |
Mindfulness to Enhance Quality of Life and Support Advance Care Planning (MEANING) intervention | no change | caregiver burden | caregivers | not statistically significant | were not statistically significant | #10 |
Mindfulness to Enhance Quality of Life and Support Advance Care Planning (MEANING) intervention | no change | depressive symptoms | patients and caregivers | not statistically significant | were not statistically significant | #11 |
Mindfulness to Enhance Quality of Life and Support Advance Care Planning (MEANING) intervention | no change | anxiety | patients and caregivers | not statistically significant | were not statistically significant | #12 |
Mindfulness to Enhance Quality of Life and Support Advance Care Planning (MEANING) intervention | no change | sleep disturbance | patients and caregivers | not statistically significant | were not statistically significant | #13 |
Mindfulness to Enhance Quality of Life and Support Advance Care Planning (MEANING) intervention | no change | cognitive avoidance | patients and caregivers | not statistically significant | were not statistically significant | #14 |
Mindfulness to Enhance Quality of Life and Support Advance Care Planning (MEANING) intervention | no change | peaceful acceptance of cancer | patients and caregivers | not statistically significant | were not statistically significant | #15 |
usual care | no change | existential well-being | usual care patients | - | did not | #16 |
usual care | no change | self-efficacy for advance care planning | usual care patients | - | did not | #17 |
- | increase | readiness to engage in advance care planning | Patients in both conditions | small to moderate increases | reported small to moderate increases | #18 |
BACKGROUND: Patients with advanced cancer and family caregivers often use avoidant coping strategies, such as delaying advance care planning discussions, which contribute to deterioration in their quality of life. Mindfulness-based interventions have shown promise in improving quality of life in this population but have rarely been applied to advance care planning. This pilot trial examined the preliminary efficacy of a group-based Mindfulness to Enhance Quality of Life and Support Advance Care Planning (MEANING) intervention for patient-caregiver dyads coping with advanced cancer. Primary outcomes were patient and caregiver quality of life or well-being, and secondary outcomes included patient advanced care planning engagement (self-efficacy and readiness) and other psychological and symptom outcomes. METHODS: In this pilot trial, dyads coping with advanced cancer were recruited from five oncology clinics in the midwestern U.S. and randomized to six weekly group sessions of a mindfulness intervention (n = 33 dyads) or usual care (n = 22 dyads). Outcomes were assessed via surveys at baseline, post-intervention, and 1 month post-intervention. All available data were included in the multilevel models assessing intervention efficacy. RESULTS: Patients in the MEANING condition experienced significant increases in existential well-being and self-efficacy for advance care planning across follow-ups, whereas usual care patients did not. Other group differences in outcomes were not statistically significant. These outcomes included other facets of patient well-being, caregiver quality of life, patient readiness for advance care planning, caregiver burden, and patient and caregiver depressive symptoms, anxiety, sleep disturbance, cognitive avoidance, and peaceful acceptance of cancer. However, only MEANING patients showed moderate increases in psychological well-being across follow-ups, and MEANING caregivers showed moderate increases in quality of life at 1-month follow-up. Certain psychological outcomes, such as caregiver burden at 1-month follow-up, also showed moderate improvement in the MEANING condition. Patients in both conditions reported small to moderate increases in readiness to engage in advance care planning. CONCLUSIONS: A mindfulness-based intervention showed promise in improving quality-of-life and advance care planning outcomes in patients and caregivers coping with advanced cancer and warrants further testing. TRIAL REGISTRATION: ClinicalTrials.gov NCT03257007. Registered 22 August 2017, https://clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/NCT03257007 .